Common Mistakes Checklist高频错误清单

~35 min

Learning goals

  • Recognize four kinds of common mistakes, in calculations, signs, equilibrium and acids, and structure and forces
  • Find and correct mistakes in your own and others’ answers
  • Build the habit of checking against a list before handing in

Before you start

  • Unit 1–9 quick review (4.5.1)
  • How to read scoring guidelines (4.3.1)

Most lost points come from “knew it, got it wrong”

Reviewing after an exam usually shows that many lost points weren’t about not knowing the material: the same few kinds of mistakes kept coming back. Listing them and checking each one during the exam is the easiest way to win those points back.

The common-mistakes checklist

Calculations and units

  • mL not converted to L; °C not converted to K.
  • The wrong R: with P in atm and V in L, R = 0.08206; for energy, 8.314 J/(mol·K).
  • In ΔG° = −RT ln K, ΔG° must be in J; relate Ksp to solubility through the formula (MX₂: Ksp = 4s³).
  • Significant figures that don’t match the data, or intermediate results rounded too early.

Signs and directions

  • qrxn = −qsoln; if the temperature rises, ΔH < 0.
  • Bond enthalpies: ΔH = Σ broken − Σ formed, not the other way round.
  • Q < K goes forward and Q > K goes in reverse; E°cell = E°cathode − E°anode, and E° doesn’t change when you multiply by a coefficient.

Equilibrium and acids

  • A catalyst changes neither K nor the equilibrium composition; only temperature changes K.
  • Pure solids and pure liquids are left out of K expressions.
  • Weak acids ionize only partly; when a weak acid is titrated with a strong base, the equivalence pH is above 7 and the half-equivalence pH equals pKa.
  • A strong base like Ba(OH)₂ gives two OH⁻ per formula unit.

Structure and forces

  • Boiling and melting overcome intermolecular forces, not covalent bonds.
  • Polar bonds don’t make a polar molecule; check whether the shape is symmetrical.
  • An ionic solid doesn’t conduct by itself; it conducts when molten or dissolved.
  • When comparing properties, give all three links: structure → forces → property (4.3.3).
Spot the mistake: decide whether each statement is right, then see what’s wrong
  1. In 25.0 mL of 0.100 M HCl, n(HCl) = 25.0 × 0.100 = 2.50 mol.

  2. When using PV = nRT, 25 °C must be converted to 298 K.

  3. R = 8.314 J/(mol·K) can be used directly with P in atm and V in L.

  4. When using ΔG° = −RT ln K, ΔG° must first be converted from kJ to J.

This site’s mistake notebook automatically collects the questions you get wrong in practice, grouped by unit, so you can redo them any time.

Example 1: a reversed sign from bond enthalpies

A student estimates ΔH for H₂(g) + Cl₂(g) → 2HCl(g) from bond enthalpies (H–H 436, Cl–Cl 243, H–Cl 432 kJ/mol) and writes ΔH = 2(432) − (436 + 243) = +185 kJ. Find and correct the mistake.

Step-by-step solution
  1. Find the mistake. The student used “bonds formed − bonds broken,” which is backwards.

  2. Back to the principle. Breaking bonds absorbs energy (positive); forming bonds releases it (negative):

    ΔH=∑broken−∑formed\Delta H = \sum \text{broken} - \sum \text{formed}
  3. Recalculate. One H–H and one Cl–Cl break, and two H–Cl form:

    ΔH=(436+243)−2(432)=−185 kJ\begin{aligned} \Delta H &= (436 + 243) - 2(432) \\ &= \boxed{-185\ \text{kJ}} \end{aligned}
  4. Check. H₂ burning in Cl₂ is a vigorous exothermic reaction, so a negative ΔH makes sense.

A slightly soluble salt MX₂ has Ksp = 4.0 × 10⁻¹². A student writes s = √Ksp = 2.0 × 10⁻⁶ M. Find and correct the mistake.

Step-by-step solution
  1. Find the mistake. s = √Ksp only works for a 1 : 1 salt like AgCl. MX₂ dissolves to give one M²⁺ and two X⁻.

  2. Write the concentrations from the formula. MX₂(s) ⇌ M²⁺ + 2X⁻: [M²⁺] = s and [X⁻] = 2s.

  3. Substitute into Ksp.

    Ksp=s(2s)2=4s3K_{sp} = s(2s)^2 = 4s^3
  4. Solve for s.

    s=4.0×10−1243=1.0×10−4 Ms = \sqrt[3]{\frac{4.0 \times 10^{-12}}{4}} = \boxed{1.0 \times 10^{-4}\ \text{M}}
Practice: does this statement contain a mistake?
  1. A solution with pH 3 has twice the [H⁺] of a solution with pH 5
  2. Adding NaCl to a saturated AgCl solution lowers the Ksp of AgCl
  3. A reaction with ΔH < 0 and ΔS < 0 is thermodynamically favorable at low temperature
  4. Raising the temperature speeds up both endothermic and exothermic reactions
  5. Multiplying a cell reaction’s coefficients by 2 doubles E°cell
  6. One mole of any gas occupies 22.4 L at 25 °C and 1 atm
  7. When two solutions are mixed in equal volumes, each solute’s concentration halves
  8. Equal masses of CH₄ and O₂ contain the same number of molecules

Common mistakes

Mistake 1: “Reading the answer to a missed question once is enough.” Understanding an answer isn’t the same as being able to produce it. Close the answer, redo the question yourself a day or two later, and count it as learned only when you get it right.

Mistake 2: “Careless mistakes don’t matter; I’ll just be more careful.” Carelessness usually follows a pattern (always forgetting a unit conversion, always flipping a sign). Write your patterns into your checklist and check them one by one in the exam.

Mistake 3: “Significant figures don’t matter as long as the number is right.” When a result’s digits clearly don’t match the data, the scoring guidelines may take off a point. Give final answers to the data’s significant figures.

Quick check

In the last two minutes before handing in, what is most worth checking?

How many times greater is [H⁺] in a pH 2 solution than in a pH 4 solution?

What is the equilibrium expression for CaCO₃(s) ⇌ CaO(s) + CO₂(g)?

At 25 °C and 1 atm, one mole of an ideal gas occupies about:

When a half-reaction is multiplied by 2, its standard reduction potential E°:

Why does “human error” earn no credit as a source of error in a lab question?

AP-style practice

AP-style free response

Below are a student’s answers to four parts, each with a mistake. Identify each mistake and give the correct answer.

(a) Find the pH of 0.020 M Ba(OH)₂. Student: [OH⁻] = 0.020 M, pOH = 1.70, pH = 12.30.

(b) A salt dissolves in 50.0 g of water and the temperature falls by 3.2 °C. Student: q = mcΔT = (50.0)(4.18)(−3.2) = −669 J, so dissolving is exothermic.

(c) Explain why H₂O has a higher boiling point than H₂S. Student: because O–H bonds are stronger than S–H bonds and harder to break when boiling.

(d) Doubling [A] doubles the initial rate (with everything else unchanged). Student: so the reaction is second order in A.

Model answer and scoring

(a) Mistake: each formula unit of Ba(OH)₂ gives 2 OH⁻. Correct: [OH⁻] = 0.040 M, pOH = 1.40, pH = 12.60.

(b) Mistake: −669 J is q for the solution, which gave heat to the dissolving process. Correct: qdissolving = +669 J, so dissolving is endothermic.

(c) Mistake: covalent bonds don’t break when a substance boils. Correct: H₂O molecules hydrogen bond to each other (O is small and highly electronegative), while H₂S molecules have mainly weaker dipole–dipole and dispersion forces; overcoming hydrogen bonds takes more energy, so H₂O boils at a higher temperature.

(d) Mistake: a rate proportional to [A] is first order. Correct: 2ⁿ = 2, so n = 1 and the reaction is first order in A.

Scoring: 1 point per part, for identifying the mistake and giving the correct answer with its reason.

Summary

  • Common mistakes fall into four groups: calculations and units, signs and directions, equilibrium and acids, and structure and forces.
  • To fix a mistake, find the step where it went wrong, then rework from the principle (the definition, equation or formula).
  • Turn your own repeat mistakes into a checklist to review before the exam and check before handing in; redo missed questions from the notebook a few days later.

AP tip: After each practice set, write the reason for every lost point in one sentence (such as “forgot to double for Ba(OH)₂”). Reading those sentences before the exam prevents repeat mistakes better than ten new questions.

Sources: the bond enthalpies are commonly used average values; MX₂ is a hypothetical slightly soluble salt and its Ksp is illustrative.

Found a mistake in this lesson, something unclear, or have a suggestion?

Feedback / Report a problem

Type

We only receive what you write, the page you’re on and any contact you choose to leave. No names or other personal data (to stop spam we keep a one-way hash of your IP, never the IP itself).