Using a known to measure an unknown
Lesson 2.12.5 introduced acid–base titration. AP topic 4.6 treats titration as a stoichiometric method: a solution of accurately known concentration is used to measure the amount of another substance.
- The titrant滴定剂 is the solution of accurately known concentration (a standard solution) in the buret.
- The analyte待测物 is the substance being measured, in the flask.
- At the equivalence point化学计量点, the titrant added has reacted exactly with the analyte in the ratio given by the balanced equation.
- The end point滴定终点 is where the indicator changes color and the titration stops. A suitable indicator makes the end point as close to the equivalence point as possible.
Finding the equivalence point
At the equivalence point, the moles of titrant and analyte are in the coefficient ratio. For a monoprotic acid reacting 1 : 1 with NaOH:
The titration reaction must go essentially to completion for the equivalence point to be calculated accurately from moles.
Strong and weak acids: the same equivalence volume
Equal moles of a monoprotic strong acid and a monoprotic weak acid need the same amount of NaOH, because OH⁻ also reacts essentially completely with weak-acid molecules. What differs is the pH at the equivalence point: 7 for the strong acid, above 7 for the weak acid (the CH₃COO⁻ formed is a weak base).
Halfway to the equivalence point, a weak acid solution contains equal amounts of CH₃COOH and CH₃COO⁻, and the pH is about equal to pKₐ. Drag the slider to watch the particles in the flask change:
The titration curves show the same thing: both jumps come at about 25.00 mL.
Redox titrations
A titration reaction doesn’t have to be acid–base. In acidic solution, Fe²⁺ can be titrated with KMnO₄:
- MnO₄⁻ and Fe²⁺ react in a 1 : 5 ratio.
- No added indicator is needed. MnO₄⁻ is purple and Mn²⁺ is nearly colorless. Before the equivalence point, each drop of MnO₄⁻ loses its color at once; after the Fe²⁺ is used up, one more drop turns the solution pale pink: the end point.
- The reaction uses up H⁺, so the pH gradually rises.
KMnO₄ can also titrate H₂O₂: , a 2 : 5 ratio.
Technique and errors
- Buret: after washing with distilled water, rinse it two or three times with the titrant. Otherwise leftover water dilutes the titrant, more volume is needed, and the calculated analyte concentration is too high.
- Flask: it doesn’t need to be dry, and it must not be rinsed with the analyte. Water in the flask doesn’t change the moles of analyte; rinsing with analyte adds more.
- Reading: read the bottom of the meniscus at eye level, to 0.01 mL.
- Discarding data: run several trials and discard one that is clearly out of line with the others (often a misread buret or an overshot end point) before averaging.
- Primary standards: NaOH solutions are often standardized with potassium hydrogen phthalate (KHP, KHC₈H₄O₄). If the KHP is wet, part of the weighed mass is water, so there’s less KHP than calculated; less NaOH is needed, and the calculated NaOH concentration is too high.
- Measuring a gas volume: collect the gas in a water-filled eudiometer (gas-measuring tube) inverted in water, and read the gas volume directly.
Example 1: Standardizing NaOH with KHP
0.5105 g of KHP (molar mass 204.22 g/mol) is dissolved in water and titrated with NaOH solution; the end point comes at 25.00 mL. KHP and NaOH react 1 : 1. Find the molarity of the NaOH. How would wet KHP affect the result?
-
Moles of KHP. KHP is the weighed primary standard, so its moles come from its mass (in mol):
-
Moles of NaOH from the ratio. At the end point they have reacted exactly 1 : 1:
-
Molarity of NaOH. Convert the volume to liters: 25.00 mL = 0.02500 L:
-
Error analysis: wet KHP. First, which quantity is off? Part of the 0.5105 g is water, so the actual KHP is less than 2.500 × 10⁻³ mol and the NaOH volume V used is smaller. Then, where does it sit in the formula? The calculation still uses 0.5105 g (numerator unchanged) while the smaller V is in the denominator, so the calculated molarity is too high.
-
Check significant figures. 0.5105 and 25.00 both have 4, so the answer has 4.
Example 2: A redox titration
25.00 mL of a solution containing Fe²⁺ is acidified and titrated with 0.0200 M KMnO₄; the solution turns pale pink after 18.40 mL. Find the concentration of Fe²⁺.
-
Write the mole ratio. In acid, is reduced to (gaining 5 electrons) and is oxidized to (losing 1). Balancing electrons:
and react in a 1 : 5 mole ratio.
-
Moles of . In mol:
-
Convert to with the 1 : 5 ratio.
-
Concentration of .
-
The end point. is purple and nearly colorless; once the is used up, one extra drop of turns the solution pale pink. indicates its own end point, so no indicator is added.
- The buret wasn't rinsed with the NaOH solution
The NaOH is diluted, so a larger volume is used.
- The flask was still wet with distilled water
Water doesn't change the moles of acid.
- The flask was rinsed with the acid being analyzed
Extra acid in the flask uses more NaOH.
- An air bubble in the buret tip disappears during the titration
The volume read includes the bubble, so it's too large.
- The final buret reading is read from above the meniscus
The final reading is too small, so the volume is too small.
- The initial buret reading is read from below the meniscus
The initial reading is too large, so the volume is too small.
- The end point is overshot, and the solution turns deep pink
Too much NaOH is added.
- Some acid splashes out of the flask while swirling
Less acid remains, so less NaOH is used.
- The NaOH was standardized with wet KHP
The recorded NaOH molarity is too high, so the acid concentration calculated from it is too high.
- A drop is left hanging on the buret tip at the end point
The reading includes a drop that never reached the flask, so the volume is too large.
Common mistakes
Mistake 1: “The equivalence point is where the pH is 7.” That’s true only for a strong acid titrated with a strong base. A weak acid titrated with a strong base has an equivalence-point pH above 7; a weak base titrated with a strong acid, below 7.
Mistake 2: “A weak acid only partly ionizes, so it never reaches the equivalence point.” OH⁻ reacts essentially completely with weak-acid molecules, so equal moles of a weak and a strong acid use the same amount of base.
Mistake 3: “The end point is the equivalence point.” The end point is where the indicator changes color; the equivalence point is set by moles. Only with a suitable indicator are the two very close.
Quick check
25.00 mL of 0.100 M HCl and 25.00 mL of 0.100 M CH₃COOH are each titrated with 0.100 M NaOH. How do the volumes of NaOH needed to reach the equivalence point compare?
The equivalence point is set by moles, not by acid strength. What differs is the pH at the equivalence point.
Which titration technique is correct?
Rinsing the buret with titrant keeps it from being diluted. The flask must not be rinsed with analyte and needn't be dry; buret readings use the bottom of the meniscus.
Four titrations use 24.86 mL, 24.90 mL, 26.95 mL, and 24.88 mL of NaOH. How should the data be handled?
26.95 mL is clearly out of line, probably a misread buret or an overshot end point, so it's discarded. The other three agree closely and are averaged.
Wet KHP is used to standardize a NaOH solution. How is the calculated NaOH molarity affected, and why?
M(NaOH) = n(KHP) ÷ V. The n(KHP) used in the calculation (from the weighed mass) is too large while V is too small, so the result is too high.
Acidified Fe²⁺ solution is titrated with KMnO₄ solution, with no indicator added. How is the end point recognized?
Once the Fe²⁺ is used up, a slight excess of purple MnO₄⁻ is no longer decolorized, and the solution turns pale pink. KMnO₄ is its own indicator.
How does the pH change during the titration of Fe²⁺ with KMnO₄ (MnO₄⁻ + 5Fe²⁺ + 8H⁺ → Mn²⁺ + 5Fe³⁺ + 4H₂O)?
H⁺ is a reactant, so it's consumed; [H⁺] decreases and the pH rises. The oxidation number of H doesn't change, but its concentration does.
The Mg(OH)₂ in an antacid tablet is titrated with 0.500 M HCl, reaching the equivalence point at 24.60 mL: Mg(OH)₂ + 2HCl → MgCl₂ + 2H₂O. What mass of Mg(OH)₂ is in the tablet?
n(HCl) = 0.500 × 0.02460 = 0.01230 mol, so n(Mg(OH)₂) = 0.01230 ÷ 2 = 0.006150 mol and m = 0.006150 × 58.33 = 0.359 g. A forgets to divide by 2; C is the moles of HCl.
Which apparatus is best for measuring the volume of H₂ produced when magnesium reacts with hydrochloric acid?
H₂ is barely soluble in water, so it displaces the water in the eudiometer and its volume can be read directly. An open beaker can't hold the gas; a stoppered flask gives no volume reading and may pop its stopper.
AP-style free response
A student titrates 20.00 mL of hydrochloric acid of unknown concentration with 0.1000 M NaOH, using phenolphthalein as the indicator. The volumes of NaOH used in four trials are:
| Trial | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| V(NaOH) (mL) | 21.42 | 21.38 | 23.10 | 21.40 |
(a) Explain the difference between the equivalence point and the end point. What is observed at the end point in this experiment?
(b) Which trials should be used? Calculate the concentration of the hydrochloric acid.
(c) If the buret had been washed with distilled water but not rinsed with the NaOH solution, would the calculated HCl concentration be too high or too low? Justify your answer.
(d) If the analyte were 20.00 mL of acetic acid of the same concentration, what volume of NaOH would reach the equivalence point? Would the pH at the equivalence point be equal to, greater than, or less than 7?
Model answer and scoring
(a) The equivalence point is where the moles of OH⁻ added exactly equal the moles of H⁺ present; the end point is where the indicator changes color and the titration stops. Here, at the end point the solution turns from colorless to pale pink after the last drop of NaOH, and the color lasts for half a minute.
(b) Trial 3 (23.10 mL) is clearly out of line and is discarded. Average volume = (21.42 + 21.38 + 21.40) ÷ 3 = 21.40 mL. [HCl] = 0.1000 × 21.40 ÷ 20.00 = 0.1070 M.
(c) Too high. The leftover water dilutes the NaOH, so a larger volume is needed to reach the end point, and [HCl] = M(NaOH)V(NaOH) ÷ V(HCl) comes out too high.
(d) The acetic acid has the same number of moles as the HCl, so it also needs 21.40 mL. At the equivalence point the solution contains CH₃COO⁻, a weak base, so the pH is greater than 7.
Scoring: (a) 1 point for each definition and 1 for the end-point observation; (b) trial 3 discarded, 0.1070 M; (c) too high, explained by the larger volume; (d) 21.40 mL, pH greater than 7.
Summary
- The titrant is in the buret and the analyte in the flask; the equivalence point is set by moles, and the end point is shown by the indicator.
- Equal moles of a monoprotic strong acid and weak acid use the same amount of base, but the pH at the equivalence point differs.
- KMnO₄ titrates Fe²⁺ in a 1 : 5 ratio with no added indicator, turning pale pink at the end point; the reaction uses up H⁺, so the pH rises.
- Rinse the buret with titrant; don’t rinse the flask; discard clearly out-of-line data; a wet primary standard makes the standardized molarity too high.
AP tip: For titration-error questions, first decide which measured quantity (a volume or a mass) the mistake makes too large or too small, then follow it through the calculation to get the direction of the error. Naming the quantity that changed earns more credit than “too high” or “too low” alone.