One force explains a whole unit
An atom is a positively charged nucleus (protons and neutrons) surrounded by negatively charged electrons. Nearly everything in U1.5 through U1.8 can be explained by one force: the Coulombic attraction between the nucleus and the electrons, together with the repulsion between electrons. That covers how electrons are arranged, where PES peaks appear, how radius and ionization energy change, and what charge an ion takes.
Lesson 2.3.2 used Coulomb’s law qualitatively to explain periodic trends. AP asks for more: proportional reasoning with the law, and explanations that name both factors, charge and distance.
Proportional reasoning with Coulomb’s law
The force between two charged particles is
For a nucleus and one electron, is the nuclear charge the electron feels (more precisely, the effective nuclear charge, since core electrons shield part of it), is the electron’s charge, and is the distance between them. Proportional reasoning only needs the factors:
- Double a charge and the force doubles.
- Double the distance and the force drops to 1/4.
- When both change, multiply the factors: charge × 2 and distance × 2 give 2 × 1/4 = 1/2 of the force.
So whenever you compare the attraction on two electrons, ask two questions: What nuclear charge does it feel? How far from the nucleus is it (which shell)? Drag the charge and distance on sides A and B, then try the two presets that use real data:
Electron configurations, the AP way
Lesson 2.2.5 covered the aufbau principle, the Pauli exclusion principle, and Hund’s rule. AP questions come at them from these angles:
- Core and valence electrons. Core electrons match a noble-gas configuration and sit close to the nucleus; valence electrons are in the outermost shell and control an element’s chemistry.
- Ions. Anions add electrons in aufbau order: is 1s²2s²2p⁶. Cations lose electrons from the highest n first, so transition metals lose 4s before 3d: Mn is [Ar]4s²3d⁵, is [Ar]3d⁵, and is [Ar]3d⁴.
- Unpaired electrons. Draw the orbital diagram (by Hund’s rule, electrons occupy a sublevel’s orbitals singly before pairing) and count the single arrows: O has 2, N has 3, and has 5.
- Highest-energy electron. For main-group elements, look at the last sublevel filled: for Ga it’s 4p. For transition metals, separate “filled last” (3d) from “lost first” (4s).
US textbooks and AP usually write configurations in filling order ([Ar]4s²3d⁶), while Chinese textbooks write them by shell ([Ar]3d⁶4s²); AP accepts both. AP doesn’t ask you to write the exceptions such as Cr and Cu.
Pick an element and a charge to see the configuration, orbital diagram, and unpaired electrons. Be sure to try Mn, , and :
Ground state, excited state, or impossible?
- Ground state: follows the aufbau principle, the Pauli principle, and Hund’s rule; it is the lowest-energy arrangement.
- Excited state: the right number of electrons, but at least one sits in a higher sublevel while a lower one still has room, such as Be as 1s²2s¹2p¹ or Mg as [Ne]3s¹3p¹. Absorbing energy produces an excited state, and returning to the ground state emits light (lesson 2.2.3).
- Impossible: breaks a sublevel’s capacity (2s³, 2p⁷) or uses a sublevel that doesn’t exist (1p, 2d, 3f).
A common trap: writing as [Ar]4s²3d⁴. The electron count is right (24), but it isn’t the ground state, because a cation loses its 4s electrons first. The ground state is [Ar]3d⁶.
Sizes of isoelectronic species
Species with the same number of electrons are isoelectronic. Each of these six has 10 electrons, in n = 1 and n = 2:
| Species | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Protons | 7 | 8 | 9 | 11 | 12 | 13 |
| Ionic radius (pm) | 146 | 140 | 133 | 102 | 72 | 54 |
(Shannon effective ionic radii; four-coordinate for , six-coordinate for the rest.)
The Coulombic explanation: the electrons and shells are the same, so electron–electron repulsion is about the same; more protons pull harder on that same set of electrons and draw them in closer, so the radius is smaller. That’s the reasoning AP accepts. These two claims earn no credit: “a neutral atom has zero net charge, so its electrons feel no attraction” (every electron is attracted by the nucleus), and “a cation’s positive charge increases the repulsion between its electrons” (repulsion depends on the number of electrons, which is the same).
Removing electrons from different sublevels
Within one atom, the energy needed to remove an electron depends strongly on its sublevel. Core electrons are close to the nucleus and hardly shielded, so they are attracted far more strongly; valence electrons are far away and shielded by the core, so they are the easiest to remove. By Coulomb’s law, a 1s electron in sodium is the hardest to remove, then 2s and 2p, and the 3s electron is the easiest. Photoelectron spectroscopy, in U1.6, measures these energies directly.
Example 1: The configuration of Mn³⁺
Write the ground-state configuration of and give its number of unpaired electrons.
-
Start with the neutral atom. Mn is element 25; by the aufbau order it fills up to 3d:
-
Decide which electrons leave first. A cation loses its highest-n (outermost) electrons first. The 4s sublevel has n = 4, higher than 3d (n = 3), so both 4s electrons go first:
-
Remove one more electron. The 4s sublevel is now empty, so the third electron comes from 3d:
-
Count unpaired electrons. The 3d sublevel has 5 orbitals. By Hund’s rule, the 4 electrons occupy 4 separate orbitals with parallel spins, so none has to pair:
- ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ □
There are unpaired electrons.
-
Check the electron count. Mn has 25 electrons, so has 22; [Ar] gives 18 and 3d gives 4, for 22. It checks.
Example 2: Ranking an isoelectronic series
Rank , , , and from largest to smallest radius, and explain.
-
Find what they share (count electrons). Electrons = protons − charge:
- : 16 + 2 = 18
- : 17 + 1 = 18
- : 19 − 1 = 18
- : 20 − 2 = 18
All four have 18 electrons in the configuration 1s²2s²2p⁶3s²3p⁶: they are isoelectronic.
-
Find how they differ (compare protons). The electrons and shells are the same; the only difference is nuclear charge: S 16, Cl 17, K 19, Ca 20.
-
Connect it to radius (Coulomb’s law). With the same shells, more protons pull the same 18 electrons more strongly, drawing the electron cloud in and giving a smaller radius:
-
Check with data. Shannon ionic radii are 184, 181, 138, and 100 pm, in the same order.
-
How to write it on the exam. State “same number of electrons (same shells)”, then “different numbers of protons”, then “more protons, stronger attraction, smaller radius”. “Anions are big and cations are small” is not an explanation.
- O atom: 1s²2s²2p⁴
All 8 electrons are in aufbau order: ground state.
- Be atom: 1s²2s¹2p¹
A 2s electron has moved up to 2p while 2s still has room: excited state.
- Li atom: 1s²2s³
An s sublevel holds at most 2 electrons, so 2s³ can't exist (and the electron count is wrong too).
- Mg atom: 1s²2s²2p⁶3s¹3p¹
A 3s electron has moved up to 3p: excited state.
- F atom: 1s²2s²2p⁷
A p sublevel has 3 orbitals and holds at most 6 electrons.
- : [Ar]3d⁴
Remove both 4s electrons, then one 3d electron: ground state.
- : [Ar]4s²3d⁴
The electron count is right, but a cation loses its 4s electrons first; the ground state is [Ar]3d⁶, so this higher-energy arrangement is an excited state.
- Li atom: 1s²2p¹
2s is empty while an electron sits in 2p: excited state.
- K atom: 1s²2s²2p⁶3s²3p⁶3d¹
4s is lower in energy than 3d, so ground-state potassium's last electron is in 4s.
- Ca atom: 1s²2s²2p⁶3s²3p⁶3f²
The n = 3 shell has only s, p, and d sublevels; there is no 3f.
- : 1s²2s²2p⁶3s²3p⁶
Chlorine gains 1 electron to fill 3p: ground state, isoelectronic with Ar.
Common mistakes
Mistake 1: “A transition metal forming a cation loses the 3d electrons it filled last.” Cations lose electrons from the highest n first. Fe is [Ar]4s²3d⁶, and is [Ar]3d⁶, not [Ar]4s²3d⁴.
Mistake 2: “Electrons in a sublevel pair up first.” By Hund’s rule, electrons occupy separate orbitals of a sublevel with parallel spins before any pairing. Nitrogen’s 2p³ has 3 unpaired electrons, not 1.
Mistake 3: “Isoelectronic species have the same electrons, so they’re the same size” or “a cation’s positive charge increases repulsion, so it’s bigger.” Isoelectronic species have the same electrons but different numbers of protons. More protons attract the electrons more strongly, so the radius is smaller: is 133 pm but only 102 pm.
Quick check
An electron's distance from the nucleus doubles, and the effective nuclear charge it feels also doubles. The attractive force on it becomes
F ∝ q/r²: charge × 2, and doubling the distance multiplies the force by 1/4, so the net factor is 2 × 1/4 = 1/2.
Which statement correctly compares the radii of and and gives a valid reason?
Both have 10 electrons in the same two shells; Na has 11 protons and F only 9. Choice B fails because repulsion depends on the number of electrons. Measured: 102 pm, 133 pm.
How many unpaired electrons does a ground-state ion have?
Fe is [Ar]4s²3d⁶. Remove the two 4s electrons, then one 3d electron: is [Ar]3d⁵, with each of the 5 electrons alone in a 3d orbital.
The ground-state configuration of an element X is [Ne]3s²3p⁴. The formula of the compound X forms with magnesium is most likely
3s²3p⁴ means 6 valence electrons; gaining 2 more reaches the Ar configuration, giving (X is sulfur). Magnesium loses 2 electrons to become , so charge balance gives MgX, that is, MgS.
In a ground-state Ga atom, the highest-energy electron is in which sublevel?
Ga is [Ar]4s²3d¹⁰4p¹, so the last electron added, the highest in energy, is in 4p. Ground-state Ga has no 4d electrons.
AP-style free response
(a) Write the ground-state electron configuration of and give its number of unpaired electrons.
(b) A student writes the configuration of as [Ar]4s²3d³. Identify the error.
(c) Rank , , , and from largest to smallest radius. Justify your ranking using Coulomb’s law.
Model answer and scoring
(a) [Ar]3d⁵ (or 1s²2s²2p⁶3s²3p⁶3d⁵). The five 3d electrons each occupy their own orbital, so there are 5 unpaired electrons.
(b) A cation loses electrons from the highest n first, which means the 4s electrons, not the 3d electrons filled last. [Ar]4s²3d³ removes two 3d electrons instead; the count is right, but it isn’t the ground state.
(c) > > > . All four have 18 electrons in the same three shells, so the repulsion between electrons is about the same. Their numbers of protons are 16, 17, 19, and 20; the more protons, the stronger the Coulombic attraction for those electrons, the closer they’re pulled in, and the smaller the radius.
Scoring: (a) correct configuration and unpaired count; (b) states that the highest-n (4s) electrons are lost first; (c) correct order, with both “same electrons (same shells)” and “different numbers of protons, so different attraction”; “more positive charge, so smaller” alone earns no credit.
Summary
- Coulomb’s law: . The attraction an electron feels depends on effective nuclear charge and distance; in proportional reasoning, multiply the two factors.
- Anions add electrons in aufbau order; cations lose electrons from the highest n first, so transition metals lose 4s first: is [Ar]3d⁴.
- Draw orbital diagrams by Hund’s rule and count single arrows for unpaired electrons. An electron in a higher sublevel while a lower one has room means an excited state; overfilled or nonexistent sublevels mean an impossible configuration.
- Isoelectronic species: same electrons and shells, so more protons means stronger attraction and a smaller radius.
AP tip: A Coulomb’s-law explanation must address both factors: charge (nuclear or effective nuclear charge, meaning protons and shielding) and distance (which shell the electron is in). Words like “stable” or “filled” can’t replace that explanation. Transition-metal cations losing 4s first is a favorite question; AP doesn’t ask you to write exceptions such as Cr and Cu. In U1.6, photoelectron spectroscopy measures the energy of the electrons in every sublevel directly.